| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 12:30:00 -
[1]
OK i was wondering.
We have dreads which are rock We have carriers which are scissors We have sub-caps which are paper
Dreads beat carriers. Carriers beat subcaps. But there is slight problem: Subcaps dont work too well vs dread gangs. So am i missing some obvious counter to dreads or is it only "bring the bigger rock than they have"?
Was also discussing a bit about cap ship counters. Just some random ideas: 1. removing EWar from dreads = forces cap gangs to have support to actually remove enemy ewar 2. bringing something like massive stealth bomber which works only against cap ships. Even lets say around 100 000 damage per salvo but "bomb" can be targetted mid flight and destroyed (hello destroyer ship class? its been useless for ages now so it might become useful at least).
Anyways - what im saying bring some more player skill into cap fights because atm its who brings more wins (or who is lagged less in non-RF system).
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 12:44:00 -
[2]
Originally by: Gnomes Rock Edited by: Gnomes Rock on 21/12/2008 12:34:36 You bring a dread fleet vs a battleship fleet. The dreads will die, it'll just take a while.
Edit; aslong as the battleship gang has a few hictors
You are soooo dead wrong :) If enemy brings 80-100 dreads and you bring 100ish battleships there is no chance in hell you will win. Remember dread (not sieged) deals around 500dps (more than sniper battleship) unless its a moros (then its 1000+) while mantaining much better buffer tank.
But yeh - its not like we didnt kill dreads with BS gangs. Did you?
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 13:12:00 -
[3]
Originally by: MotherMoon
if those 100 battleships kill 50 dreads but all 100 battleships are lost. Then the team with the battleships won.
Except they will not kill 50 dreads. Unless you have actual proof that this happened in the past?
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 14:08:00 -
[4]
i always thought 50 dreads IF they enter siege can break 10 carriers quite... fast. But yeah checking movie, when it DLs that is
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 14:38:00 -
[5]
Originally by: Nhaz 10 Moros will beat off 10 carriers so long as are smart about it.
a Moros with heavy's and sentries easily kick the crap out of all the fighters from the carriers or if they are in a hurry just concentrate on a single carrier with the sentries and watch it die fast.
The carriers need to neut the crap out of one of the Moros asap in order to keep up.
This is a battle of a who can pull their drones in fastest before one dies. since, the heavys from a moros will pretty much two volley a fighter.
I was more looking at just straight firing at carrier. 10 carrier RR will not keep up with 10 dread damage.
carrier RR's 300dps/1 module so if everyone is set properly - thats 600dps negated. Including resists its around 1200-1500. Dreads deal around 3500dps so thats 2000 leaking. Times 10 dreads = 20 000 hp vanishing per second. Thus under minute per carrier. Carriers wont neut one dread dry in one minute.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.21 15:37:00 -
[6]
Im talking about so called "engame" problem not some random fights where you can bring 4x more BS than they have dreads. Im talking about the situation when you can bring both BS and dread and always bring dread to the table. Yeh - 200+ man dread gangs which can be ONLY killed by another dread gang.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 06:28:00 -
[7]
Originally by: PeachesAndCream Deva, you must be smoking something. A sniper battleship does on average 400-500 DPS, more if its Amarr. A revelation has the best long range DPS, and its roughly 100 per gun outside of siege or ~300 dps. And unlike dreads vs POS, citadel torp speed would make those dreads worthless in a fleet fight.
Second, what is the point of sniping dreads? That would be helping the dreads track, and they still track horribly outside of siege. Only a Moros's drones (or sentries) would have any conceivable threat, and two equally matched fleets are usually going to be 25-30% Moroses.
Dread fleet vs BS fleet. Dread fleet gets murdered. There's also the part where one dread is worth a dozen BS, and more likely to be packing faction/deadspace/slaves.
Im just saying that you can number crunch all you want. And when one side deploys 150ish dreads there is not much you can do even if you can muster 200ish people. Been there, done that. Did you?
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 13:52:00 -
[8]
Originally by: geno effort Edited by: geno effort on 22/12/2008 10:27:04 All this problem arose from, and started with capital hitpoint buff a little over a year ago, plus rigs. It used to be far more viable to kill capitals with subcapitals, when for 10 times the cost they didn't have 40-50 times more EHP than battleships. Even the capital-heavy veteran alliances spoke against that change back in the day, IIRC.
Cant not agree here. But removing their HP would have much more consequences = being more prone to multi-DD (which WILL come off sooner or later versus caps).
Quote:
Yes. You are missing NOS/Neuts. Sieged dreads wont hit crap and unsieged ones can't fight their way out of wet paper bag.
Nos/neuts are useless vs whole dread fleets. They might be good vs 1-5 dreads (while you have like 20 BS total) but as soon as numbers reach "critical mass" its just better to add more DPS instead of playing cap warfare.
Quote:
Also the main reason why 150 BS loose is because if you have 150 dreads on field you also have 2 + titans ready to jump in and obliterate those 150 snipers.
And here we go back to the beggining. Sub caps are useless vs caps because there are specific caps that can kill any sub-cap they can find in one go. Thus rock-paper-scissors circle (actually its way larger but w/ever) is again screwed up.
So lemme guess when CCP is gonna acknowledge "caps-online" issue: as soon as only subcaps needed will be cyno ships. Amrite?
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 19:22:00 -
[9]
Originally by: PeachesAndCream
Originally by: Deva Blackfire Im just saying that you can number crunch all you want. And when one side deploys 150ish dreads there is not much you can do even if you can muster 200ish people. Been there, done that. Did you?
I've probably been in more dread battles than you. In a 1 to 1 comparison of the two ships, a battleship does more damage and has less HP. The major difference is in tracking and lock times. In siege, the dreads are screwed, especially at close range. Out of siege they are susceptible to EWAR, and still have terrible tracking.
Your scenario is ridiculous because it's never been that perfect. A BS fleet needs dictors to keep the dreads from jumping out, and dreads usually have some support. The times when they don't, they have a doomsday or two backing them. Or carriers in their gang. Then there's the part where a BS fleet wouldn't lose in a perfect scenario because dreads can't tackle them, and so on..
Given 150 dreads vs 200 bs where neither side could run away, I'd choose to be on the BS side because it would win hands down.
Ofc im counting support. Thought it was obvious...
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.22 20:55:00 -
[10]
Originally by: Straight Chillen Edited by: Straight Chillen on 22/12/2008 20:46:06 But then again, Dont all battles in eve basically end up as who brings more?
When we look at sub-caps? No. You can win even having 3:1 or 4:1 odds doing strafe runs, keeping distance, having logistics working properly etc. On cap ship level its almost impossible to win while having 1,5:1 odds. Problems arise when one side can use caps other cant (cyno jammed systems anyone?) - suddenly there is not much you can do except logging off for the night.
As for ganking dreads while having 5:1 or more numbers - uhm its overkill. Tho it still depends on numbers. If you have 20 rr BS vs 10 dreads - its doable (and not that hard). If you have 60 vs 30 dreads its starting to get tricky (depends on amount of moroses). 60 dreads? ugh this hurts (+ lag generated and stuff which reduces rr BS effectiveness). At some point BS's just pop so fast you cant rep em.
(yes it is counting support, ewar, maybe odd dozen of carriers on dreads side).
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 09:36:00 -
[11]
Edited by: Deva Blackfire on 24/12/2008 09:38:29 Edited by: Deva Blackfire on 24/12/2008 09:37:30
Originally by: Kagura Nikon
150 dreads vs 150 BS, but without titan support are just a huge isk sink. Specially if the BSs are APOCs and Rokhs at 200 km. At end the dreads might even kill more ships. But the dread side wil ahve lost 10 times more isk.
Told you already: include support ships on both sides, maybe a dozen carriers on dread side. And suddenly those BS wont even be able break to RR from carriers.
EDIT: also its not like everyone brings 150apocs to fleet fights. Even now with "oh so uber rokhs and apocs" megas and pests are usually at least 50% of the fleet composition.
I still see lots of EFT-theorycrafting but no actual look how it does actually work IN game.
Oh yea i do have dread (cap fight setup so 1 rep and EHP) but never used it in combat. Reason? My rock was smaller than theirs so no point at all to suicide.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 13:52:00 -
[12]
Originally by: Random Womble what i find ammusing is you are just sticking to BSs vs dreads diffrence i mean if you get cruisers vs BS you would not expect 100 cruisers to kill 100 BS
Its quite doable. (was trying to find KB link but its buried somewhere deep so i cba to look anymore)
Quote:
rest of wall of text
So you are saying that cap ship blobs are fine? And everyone enjoys being one of 100-200-300 whatever caps you can bring?
Also if you are being one hard-pressed by dread blob there is no option of "let them be, we will come for them later". They are used primarily as offensive tool and nowadays cap blobs are sure way to go. Why? Because smaller enemy (be it corp/alliance) can not hope to counter it without sizeable cap fleet at their disposal.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 22:39:00 -
[13]
Thing is: you CAN win the fight if you have 25% of enemy numbers while heaviest ship used is battleship. Sniper BS/support dies so easily that even doing warp in-kill one-warp out strafe runs will win you a fight. With caps it just doesnt work. Neither caps can do strafe runs vs other caps nor BS will be able to kill one and warp off before getting blobbed to hell and back.
Yeh main point here is the total amount of HP caps have nowadays. Back before caps got HP boosted it was possible to snipe em and GTFO, nowadays it just isnt. You need to stay on field and "stay on field" gameplay is almost always won by bigger blob.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 23:10:00 -
[14]
Originally by: Random Womble As people have said you still can kill a dread before he can lock you back even with what now would be considered a moderately sized gang.
If said dreads have at least some support (especially in form of carriers) then you cant hope to crack them open. Average RR carrier reps 300 dps per RR = 600 dps per 2x RR mods (normal amoun in cap warfare). Add resist and its 1200-1500. Its the amount of damage dealt by 4-5 snipers or 2-3 rr battleships. But using rr battleships against drone/fighter swarm is a suicide (a bit of lag and there goes your fleet).
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.25 10:02:00 -
[15]
Originally by: Kagura Nikon
Remote rep does not work on dreads on siege. And if you even start talking about dreads fighting out of siege you are just making yourself look dumb (sorry but its the truth)
Welcome to the "i ran out of the arguments, need to insult" world. Why exactly is it stupid? Because you can actually hit something? Because your guns still deal nice damage? Because you CAN be remote repped?
We all know sieged dread suck vs anything that isnt capital or pos so why you insist on using sieged dread vs subcaps? See - i guess your lots of dread piloting experience ends with "f1 lock, f2, pos dead, cyno out". Try something else and yes it does work. And works even better if you have moros (sentries on that ship rock if you didnt know, and no need to siege at all).
Quote:
Capitals did received a too huge HP boost. That is a fact. But its also a fact that on the numbers people are arguing here (150+ battleships) you CAN kill a dread in under 1 minute. And STOP with the @!@^!@#!$! idea that a carrier can do anything to help DREADS IN SIEGE.
Like i said above: why siege when enemy has no caps on you is beyond me. You siege when caps arrive - then you have grid loading advantage. Other than that there is absolutely no need to stay in siege mode.
Quote:
Blobs are too big in eve now. If capitals have their HP reduced NOW, they would become worthless. Something DIFFERENT must be arranged now, maybe the subsystems idea, I don't know. But while less HP would have been a solution when BLOBS were 200 ships, its not a solution when blobs are 500 + ships.
Why game system should scale towards large battles? because its the only way YOU can play? Or maybe lets scale it for 50ish man gangs and laugh at those who try to play larger ones because everything dies so fast? Why should i get penalized for fighting in 20 man gang because "im not at 500 man blob yet"? Your stupid 500 man blobs are STILL one of the rarest engagements in the game if you didnt know.
Quote:
Wha t i think can be done is the oposite. Increase EHP of BATTLESHIPS, so they can live a bit longer.
And here we go: you are thinking only about some screwed up 500 man blobs ignoring the fact that most of the combat is still small scale. And yes improving BS HP will again screw up this balance: more redocking games, even harder to kill RR and non-RR gangs. hell even killing solo BS before his backup arrives takes way too long nowadays.
And when it comes to HP progression the one on dreads is just screwed up: ship: cruiser - battleship - dread cost: ~10m - ~100m - ~1,5b hp: ~20k - ~100k - ~2000k(2m)
So you get 10x price increase 5x buffer increase, wheras on BS to dread you get 15x price increase but 20x buffer increase. Even if you play a bit with numbers (add mods/rigs stuff) dreads are still way off of this progression. And is quite easy to see looking at this progression that motherships and titans do have quite low hitpoints compared to what they should have (and i do agree they are a bit weak in this department). Also its quite easy to see that instead of 400% HP boost (as it happened before) 200% would suffice.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.25 12:15:00 -
[16]
Originally by: Random Womble Plus even if dreads are out of siege they wont fit any remote reps yes any carriers with them will but then your changing the balance of the equation your no longer talking about 100 dreads your talking about a whole mixed bag. Your complaint was about dreads on their own against sub caps but now your changing your story to try and get around the arguements given by others as to why you are wrong.
My "complaint" was about what is happening now in EVE. So if you actually play the game you should know that its never dreads alone. Also i stated MULTIPLE times in this topic that both sides have assorted support: on BS side tacklers, logistics ewar and stuff, on cap side also carriers, some odd battleships/support.
I know lots of people try to play with words but try to use common sense next time.
As for supportless cap ships: last time i saw em was in ZLZ vs TCF. TCF had only cap ships (30ish dreads + 20ish carriers?) we had around 70-80 battleships+support. No it was not possible for us to break RR circle created by carriers. All in all fight ended up as cap ship slugfest (won by ones who brought more - which is obvious), but thats another story.
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.26 12:57:00 -
[17]
Originally by: Kagura Nikon
No one with the minimal mind capability would use dreads out of siege to anything but baiting. Dreads have never been and are not the things that defeat battleships in battlefield. Every one that has been in a fleet of sub-capitals and TRIED to fight the capitals (and not hide in POS and then go to forums complain about "omg blobs", "omg you suck you have so many blues") knows that.
And here we also come to the source of a problem. If you have 300 players of which EVERY able to fly dread, carrier, BS. What will you ask for gang? Battleships? I doubt you will want to see even 1 of them. You will always get dreads/carriers mix .
As for hiding in POS - i think you are directing this to wrong person. I killed my own share of caps while both "defending" and attacking towers.
Anyways back on topic: if you read my 1st post you will see that i was not only proposing counter VS dreads alone but vs whole cap-ship class. Ie: the high payload, able to be defeated only by specific ship class weapons. Something that will force fleets to be mixed instead of bringing "largest ship you can fly" (+ some small mix of support, which usually ends up with alt characters flying hics/falcons/covops).
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.26 14:25:00 -
[18]
Edited by: Deva Blackfire on 26/12/2008 14:26:34
Originally by: Katarlia Simov
Just to be clear:
You do of course understand that a fleet consisting of dreads AND carriers AND Hictors AND falcons very much IS a mixed fleet, right ?
And you also further understand that most capital fleets travel around with a good mix of support ?
Its completely unclear exactly what you're arguing about at the moment.
As it stands carriers are what cause the real problems for sub-capitals, it has NOTHING to do with dreads.
When it comes to fighting amongst the big boys, its genuinely not a case of 'bring the biggest thing you can' its a matter of 'bring the most effective thing you can'. And that is mostly carriers, not becuase of them being especially unbalanced, but becuase they can do damage to a variety of ship sizes, and have their remote rep spider going on. They are the next logical progression from remote repair bs gangs for general purpose kicking the crap out of people.
Do remember by the way that capitals are pretty much only used for set piece engagements like sieges or for hot dropping. In sieges, you NEED support to lock down gates, thus forcing variety. In hot drops, you NEED something else to be the scouts and the front line force that starts the fight and lures in enough reds to make hot dropping worth the effort.
Still the problem is lack of SKILL needed in those combats. Cap ship level combats are not won by someone who is more skillful but by someone who brings more. My biggest issue here is (forget dreads - i should rewrite 1st post but cant be arsed to do so) that the game moved from the player skill towards SP and more numbers. And it is way more evident in cap ship combat where there is not muchplace for manouvers. You either click siege, f1 or lock, send fighters, rr on carrier and then you wait and see if your numbers > their rr numbers (and vice versa).
PL played with sniper dreads - that was good move but its one trick pony + wont work more than twice or three times total. Plus IIRC both times they used this "trick" they outnumbered their enemies anyways (vs goodfellas in deklein and later while helping NC in M-O or EO... or maybe it was Obe). Except for this all you are left with is numbers.
And while on sub BS level or even on BS level you CAN win if you outmanouver enemy or outsmart him (better warpins/warpouts, rolling safes, good work of anti support and dictors) on cap level you will be stuck. Sub caps vs caps will be stuck on RR ring (for the most of the time at least). Caps vs caps will be stuck in number crunching.
EDIT: as for capitals and sieges: most of the fights in 0.0 (the ones where you HAVE to commit) are sieges. CCP failed with "small gang objectives" giving us "small gang targets" which take sizeable dread gang to knock down in 1 siege cycle (cyno jammers, fitting facilities etc. 80mil HP? its more than large tower has...)
|

Deva Blackfire
coracao ardente
|
Posted - 2008.12.27 14:00:00 -
[19]
Originally by: Seishomaru
THere is no personal combat skill involved in capital gang fights and there is also none involved in sniper fleets fights, neither in NANO fleets fights neither on ANY type of combat above the very very small scale combat. And even ont aht combat the only skill requireds are to recognize by enemy ship and your own ship the correct way of engagement. After combat starts, no skills needed.
Im playing EVE-Online. Which MMO are you playing? Surely not this game.
Sniper fleets might be less skill intensive than others - its true. Same for RR BS gangs. But here it ends. When you actually try to be part of the gang instead of another clueless peon (like you stated it) you need to know YOURSELF what is better for the gang. FCs arent omnipotent and cant see everything thus lots of player decissions matter. And yes - 100 man cruiser gang will not kill 100 battleships if individual players are stupid/lack player skill. Proof? Check for p3 battles - there is a reason why 100 of tri snipers managed to fend off over 200 nanoships. And it did work other way round too - we did bring 100 nanoships vs 100 snipers and routd them (tvn area... cant remember exact system).
So yes - player skill matters. Even such dumb things as aligning ship IS player skill. Warping at 10 km to covops instead of 0 - still requires player to think. It isnt much but i saw mistakes made even in those mundane things. And when we go for cap ships - only skill required is locking/firing. O yea - and cynoing to proper cyno (and i saw people failing at this one too...).
So sorry to burst your bubble instead - try to play the game instead of being only a sheep in the flock. You are one to decide how you play the game, if you like being just a peon its not my problem. But there is lots of place left for player involvement.
|
| |
|